If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!

888-806-2588

Review of Science Writing and News Reports on DNA Testing and Popular Genetics

Richard III's New Winter of Discontent

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Shakespeare painted the last of the York rulers of England as a murderous maniac who was rightly dispatched to hell by Henry Tudor in 1485. But the story of Richard III's skeleton supposedly dug up last year in a parking lot may top that of the Bard for pulling the wool over our eyes. Or it may be the luckiest archeological find since King Tut . . . . 

The last of the York dynasty was buried in Greyfriars, Leicester, but Britons are now talking about re-interring the bones believed to be Richard's in Westminster Cathedral with England's other beloved monarchs. In 2012, a writer from Edinburgh, Philippa Langley, was walking over a particular spot in the municipal parking lot when she got goosebumps and "absolutely knew I was walking on his grave." Langley helped fund an archeological excavation and on February 4, 2013, the University of Leicester confirmed that a skeleton found in the excavation was, "beyond reasonable doubt," that of Richard III, based on a combination of evidence from radiocarbon dating, comparison with contemporary reports of his slight frame, and a comparison of his mitochondrial DNA with two matrilineal descendants of Richard III's eldest sister, Anne of York. 

Hunches and Hunchbacks

According to a BBC article, “Richard III: The Twisted Bones that Reveal a King,” the skeleton had a “striking curvature” that could only be that of the hunchback king. But according to a Daily Beast article, “Unraveling King Richard III’s Secrets,” Shakespeare wrote a century after the fact and had a pro-Tudor, anti-York political agenda. “Portraits made after his defeat that show Richard with a hump- or at least uneven shoulders- are suspect as Tudor propaganda.” There is no historical evidence of Richard III having a “striking curvature” of the spine. Or even “uneven shoulders.”  There is no evidence beyond Shakespeare of his deformity. In fact, there is historical evidence to the contrary. The article, “Richard’s Comeback,” quotes the historian, Thomas More, as saying Richard III was of “bodily shape comely enough, onely (sic) of low stature.” The Countess of Desmond reported that, at a royal ball, Richard was the ‘“handsomest man in the room . . . except for his brother, Edward, and was very well made." 

Despite historical evidence, most articles that discuss remaining doubts about the case like, “Doubts Remain that the Leicester body is Richard III,” miss this point and take it as a historical fact that Richard III had scoliosis as does the skeleton that has been found in the parking lot.

What of historical depictions of Richard III’s face? “No portraits made during his lifetime have survived  and some later copies show signs of having been altered to make him appear more sinister” (“ Richard III: The Twisted Bones”). Nevertheless, a 3D scan of the skull was taken, and a 3D face created and painted. Ashdown –Hill is quoted as telling the BBC in the article, “Richard III Facial Reconstruction Reveals Slain King More than 500 Years After His Death,”that it “largely matched” the “prominent features” in posthumous representations of the king. The artist, Janine Aitken said her part was “interpretive not scientific.” At least it is a pleasant face. But is it Richard III’s face?

Jumping to Forensic Conclusions

And the skeleton includes 10 battle wounds showing Richard III “met a violent death…”eight to the head and two to the body—which they believe were inflicted at or around the time of death. Since he died in a battle, did not other soldiers meet untimely wounds in such a manner?

Not a few scientists are waiting for peer-reviewed results. But there are none. Instead of waiting for a boring academic conference, the sponsors at the Richard III Society chose to release the results via a Hollywood style press conference. 

What kind of DNA analysis was used? Mitochondrial DNA. According to Bryony Jones in his CNN article, “Body Found under Parking Lot is King Richard III, Scientists Prove,” “the mitochondrial DNA extracted from the bones was matched to Michael Ibsen, a Canadian cabinetmaker and direct descendant of Richard III’s sister, Anne of York, and a second distant relative who wishes to remain anonymous.” Well, end of story and close that book. Right? Not so fast. Some scientists believe that the testing done was not sufficient. Why?

Mitochondrial DNA has limitations. It does reflect the deepest ancestry [see The Seven Daughters of Eve by Bryan Sykes], but is also prone to contamination [under such circumstances]( Pappas). Especially when we are discussing skeletons reminiscent of Night of the Living Dead interred improperly for centuries in damp soil. Timothy Bestor, Professor of Genetics and Development at Columbia University Medical Center, is quoted in the NY Academy of Sciences article, “Skeletal Remains of King Richard III Reportedly Discovered,” as saying that the possible quality of the [mitochondrial] DNA [under the given circumstances] was one of his key reasons for skepticism. “’After 500 years or more in a wet environment like England’s, “‘the microbes are going to degrade the DNA. It’s just food to them, ‘” says Dr. Bestor.  And Pappas quotes Maria Avila, a computational biologist at the Center for GeoGenetics at the Natural History Museum as saying, “The DNA results presented today are too weak, as they stand, to support the claim that [the] DNA [sample] is actually from Richard III…more in depth DNA analysis summed to the archaeological and osteological [bone analysis] results would make a round story [She is requesting Autosomal DNA analysis akin to what was done with the hominin discovery of the Denisovans].”  And she wonders about contamination with the type of DNA testing that was done. Avila says that, “Before being convinced of ANY atDNA study, it should be explicit that all possible cautions were taken to avoid contamination” and … “ also warned that people could share mitochondrial DNA even if they share a family tree” ( Pappas). The article, “Doubts Remain that the Leicester Body is Richard III,” a Mark Thomas at University College London is quoted as saying that “people can have matching mitochondrial DNA by chance and not be related.”

And Bestor asserts there other reasons to be skeptical, even though “Richard Buckley, lead archeologist from the University of Leicester, asserts ‘“this is beyond reasonable doubt’” based on genetic and historical forensic evidence.” Bestor argues that beyond the high risk of sample contamination, there are three other “particularly complicating factors.”  Of course, it is often an overlooked fact that “the English aristocracy reproduced within a closed gene pool in order to preserve lineages. This inbreeding results in consanguinity” (“Skeletal Remains of King Richard III”).  Dr. Bestor is quoted as saying, “ You may have the same mitochondrial haplotype, but that does not guarantee a lineal descent from a given individual.” [ Mitochondrial DNA analysis is not the same as Y haplotype DNA analysis because it focuses on deeper ancestry whereas male haplotype DNA analysis is linked to more recent male lines ]. He also points out the possibility of adoption. [The possibility of an adoption or any type of non-paternity event increases as one delves back into the distant past of any family tree]:

Another confounding factor is that, in the 17-25 generations separating King Richard’s sister from her extant relatives, there is a fair chance that children of deceased parents’ may have been adopted by their parents’ siblings somewhere along the way. After all, medieval lives were short. Such adoptions may have been kept private and excluded from historical or genealogical records. 

              

Moreover, Bestor points out that the “genetic sequences and statistical data are yet to be released” but adds that the “historical evidence is quite compelling.” According to this article, forensic evidence of the bones (1455-1540)matches with the time that Richard III was to have died ( 1485). But didn’t many people die at this same time during the same battle with similar wounds?

Astonishing or Unbelievable? Watch the University of Leicester's Full Press Conference 

Comments

Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.





Captcha Image

 

 

When Wales Was Jewish

Monday, April 02, 2012

Short answer: pre-Roman times.

As is well known, Haplogroup E1b1b1 accounts for approximately 18% to 20% of Ashkenazi and 8.6% to 30% of Sephardic Y-chromosomes. This North African type appears to be one of the major founding lineages of the Jewish population.[i]

In Britain, this quintessential Jewish type (together with J, another telltale sign of Middle Eastern roots) is absent or negligible in many towns and regions but reported in elevated frequencies in Wales (Llanidloes 7%, Llangefni 5%), the Midlands (Southwell, Nottinghamshire 12%, Uttoxeter 8%), Faversham in Kent (9%), Dorchester in the West Country with historic harbors (7%), Midhurst in West Sussex commanding ancient sea-ports (5%)  and the Channel Islands, always an important crossroads of influences (5%).[ii] Bryan Sykes’ survey of paternal clans in England and Wales confirms significant traces of the E haplogroup which he dubs Eshu in southern England (4.9%) and Wales (3.1%).[iii] It reaches its highest point in Britain in Abergele, Wales (nearly 40%), an anomaly that has been attributed to Roman soldiers of Balkan origin but may have alternative and more complex explanations.

See our blog post "Right Church, Wrong Pew," arguing that the footprint of E in Britain is attributable to North African influence, not the descendants of Roman legionnaires from the Balkans.

In 2011, Llangefni  and Wrexham in North Wales became the focus of a call for local men to provide samples of their unusual DNA. A team of scientists lead by Andy Grierson and Robert Johnston from the University of Sheffield hoped to link the migration of men from the Mediterranean to the copper mined at Parys Mountain on Anglesey and on the Great Orme promontory nearby. A preliminary analysis of 500 participants showed 30% of the men carried E1b1b, compared to 1% of men elsewhere in the United Kingdom.[iv]

Significantly, Welsh tradition associates the Iron Age hilltop town on Conwy Mountain known as Castell Caer Seion with a settlement of ancient Jews. This site overlooks Conwy Bay on the north coast of Wales and lies on the ancient road between Prestatyn in Denbighshire and Bangor in Gwynedd opposite Angelsey.  In the Black Book of Caermarthen, the Welsh national bard Taliesin casually remarks in the persona of the battling hero,

When I return from Caer Seon,

From contending with Jews,

I will come to the city of Lleu and Gwidion.[v]

Lleu and Gwidion are the names of two other legendary figures; they are believed to be historical and to have lived in the early centuries of the Common Era or anterior to it.

It is hard to avoid the thought that the hilly area to the west of the town of Conwy, in North Wales was once inhabited by Jews.


[i] A. Nebel et al, "The Y Chromosome Pool of Jews as Part of the Genetic Landscape of the Middle East", American Journal of Human Genetics69.5(2001) 1095–1112. [ii] C. Capelli et al, “A Y Chromosome Census of the British Isles,”  Current Biology 13 (2003) 979–984. [iii] Bryan Sykes, Saxons, Vikings and Celts (Norton:  2007) 206, 290. [iv] “’Extraordinary’ Genetic Make-up of North-east Wales Men,” BBC News North East Wales, article retrieved Jan. 2012 at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-north-east-wales-14173910. On Dienekes’ Anthropology Blog there is speculation about whether the main sub-clade involved is Balkan or North African E; posts and comments retrieved Jan. 2012 at http://dienekes.blogspot.com/2011/07/eastern-mediterranean-marker-in.html. [v] William F. Skene, The Four Ancient Books of Wales (Edinburgh, 1868, republished 2007 by Forgotten Books) 206.
Comments

Stephen Blevins commented on 03-Apr-2012 05:02 AM

My DNA is E1b1b1, my most distant ancestor is William Blevins (Longhunter) from the area you mentioned. My autosomal DNA places my ancestors in the orkney islands of Scotland. I'm convinced that a tribe of Jews migrated from Israel to north to Scandinavia
or Denmark and may have been apart of the invasion by Vikings to Scotland before they were found in Wales as Poweys in the Northern Mountains. Blevins comes from Blethyn meaning little wolf or (Hero) look up Ap Blethyn of Gwynedd.

Belvins Descendant commented on 12-Apr-2012 02:05 PM

I was always told the Blevins came from Wales, but in checking this story out I was unable to verify it, nor could I find any substantiation of the etymology from Bleddyn ("son of wolf"). There is not a single Blevins in the Welsh census records, although
the name is found sparsely in Cheshire, Lancashire and other northern English counties. "Formby, Wales" is actually Formby in Merseyside in Lancashaire. The -dd- element in the Welsh name Bleddyn cannot be twisted into a -v-. So go figure.

Paul commented on 28-Apr-2012 08:46 PM

My mother is a descendant of Henry Cook I of Devon. His ascendants were among the first settlers of Massachusetts and Connecticut. A great Uncle, Lemuel Cook, was the oldest surviving Revolutionary War veteran when he died at 106 years of age. We recently
had my mother's autosomal dna analyzed and found strong population matches from the Balkans (Croatia, Bosnia, Macedonia, Serbia, etc.) - which was very unexpected. There was also prominent representation form Spain and Portugal - not so unexpected. In my own
18 marker test, I had one Jewish III marker, though I can't say from whom. There is no known Judaism on either side. Sounds like your article might be describing the early Cooks. Interesting...

katarina cadieux commented on 13-Dec-2013 07:36 PM

well the language of the Welsh(Cymri)alone is very Hebraic.
here are some examples: Anudon(welsh)/ Aen Adon(hebrew)(without God)
Yni all sy-dda(welsh) / Ani El Saddai(hebrew)(I am almighty God)
Llai iachu yngwyddd achau ni(welsh) / Loa yichei neged acheinu(hebrew) ("Let him not live before our brethren")
An annos(welsh)/ ain ones(hebrew)(None did compel)
the amazing to me is how similar the words look and sound, the english is the meaning for both welsh and hebrew, their meaning are the same.
the welsh are a very ancient people even their name for themselves in their language has Crimea roots which many hebrew tribes migrated to.

Dafydd Gwilym W. Gates commented on 17-Feb-2014 11:58 AM

Katarina Cadieux 13 Dec 2013 wrote some examples to show how Welsh had parralels in Hebrew. I'm a first language Welsh speaker and couldn't make sense of the Welsh examples, I'm afraid, It wasn't Welsh.
So sorry, Dafydd

Jamie commented on 25-Aug-2014 11:15 AM

I am not surprised that Jewish (Hebrew) DNA is found in Great Britain. If people read the Bible correctly and believe what it says, they will find that when the Israelites (not Jews) went into captivity for the last time as a nation,(2,000 years ago), God sent them to the northwest, "To the Isles in the sea".

Joan Coon Deary commented on 28-Nov-2014 11:15 AM

Being female, I had my brother's DNA identified by Familytree. His Haplogroup is E1b1b1. Our male-line genealogy goes back to Dutchess County, New York, around 1775 -- all Christians as far as I can tell. There are many other people who have our surname of "Coon" and they also have had their DNA identified by Familytree. Their Haplogroup begins with an "R". Can I say definitively that we are not related to them even though they have the same surname? Am I right in thinking that is it impossible for a Haplogroup to morph from an "R" to and "E" in the course of 250 years? I've always wondered if our original surname was "Cohen" that was changed to "Coon" at some point -- but I don't think you can help me with that. Thank you for any information you can give me. Regards, Joan Coon Deary


Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.





Captcha Image

 

 


Recent Posts


Tags

Jewish GenWeb linguistics Ananya Mandal Alec Jeffreys aliyah Epigraphic Society Anasazi DNA Forums Daniel Defoe Akhenaten Grim Sleeper HapMap haplogroup T Pomponia Graecina Lithuania X chromosome Virginia DeMarce Sonora French DNA Tom Martin Scroft Tennessee Theodore Steinberg Gravettian culture DNA databases haplogroup X Hawaii genetics Tucson crosses Central Band of Cherokees Sinaloa Cohen Modal Haplotype horizontal inheritance mummies Old Souls in a New World Anacostia Indians John Ruskamp Gunnar Thompson Satoshi Horai Sarmatians Les Miserables DNA Diagnostics Center ethics hominids Chuetas Germany Sorbs Greeks Cree Indians Basques Jewish novelists megapopulations Jews Ari Plost alleles FDA Erika Chek Hayden haplogroup M genealogy haplogroup C mutation rate Philippa Langley Applied Epistemology Anne Marie Fine Juanita Sims Kari Carpenter giants Cismaru Los Lunas Decalogue Stone Wendell Paulson Louis XVI Lab Corp University of Leicester DNA testing companies Stan Steiner Patagonia Micmac Indians Pueblo Indians Colima Irish Central Thuya ENFSI Roberta Estes Eske Willerslev Beringia National Museum of Natural History Cleopatra Rafael Falk England Henry IV news Nova Scotia Jon Entine admixture Chauvet cave paintings autosomal DNA Stone Age Brian Wilkes Bulgaria Maui Zizmer Bentley surname research human leukocyte antigens Cornwall First Peoples Joseph Jacobs Ziesmer, Zizmor Mohawk Melungeon Union Algonquian Indians Wales Charlotte Harris Reese AP Gustavo Ramirez Calderon Comanche Indians Genex Diagnostics Nayarit New Mexico Silverbell Artifacts Pima Indians Current Anthropology Promega Ancestry.com Hohokam haplogroup N race Hertfordshire hoaxes Mark Thomas Freemont Indians Tintagel Navajo Indians Rutgers University William Byrd Jewish contribution to world literature Phoenicians Ukraine immunology Old World Roots of the Cherokee Cismar anthropology religion metis Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) Muslims in American history Sea Peoples gedmatch Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America Arizona State University Neanderthals Kitty Prince of the Bear River Athabaskans ethnic markers Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid Panther's Lodge Mark Stoneking Cajuns Melungeon Heritage Association myths Mary Kugler familial Mediterranean fever Clovis Terry Gross haplogroup L forensics Amy Harmon Janet Lewis Crain Stacy Schiff Normans Peter Martyr cannibalism Ashkenazi Jews Black Irish David Cornish Fritz Zimmerman crypto-Jews Valparaiso University Cocoraque Butte Joseph Andrew Park Wilson statistics Kate Wong Chris Stringer Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute Asian DNA Barnard College ged.com The Calalus Texts Sam Kean Horatio Cushman Teresa Panther-Yates haplogroup H Donald N. Yates Eric Wayner Sinti Native American DNA Robert C. Hyde Henry VII Smithsonian Institution Pueblo Grande Museum prehistory European DNA Tifaneg Israel Elizabeth DeLand Douglas C. Wallace mitochondrial DNA Cooper surname Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman Lebanon Cherokee DNA Project Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology Asiatic Fathers of America Olmec Shlomo Sand Iran Anglo-Saxons Russell Belk North African DNA Elzina Grimwood Great Goddess breast cancer Egyptians clan symbols Mother Qualla Richard Lewontin Maya Etruscans Nikola Tesla Denisovans Bryony Jones Central Band of Cherokee Melanesians Belgium DNA Fingerprint Test Arizona Nature Communications Genie Milgrom Maronites Cancer Genome Atlas 23andme Texas A&M University Telltown Navajo Signal Hill Ripan Malhi Hopi Indians Wendy Roth Marija Gimbutas El Paso Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies Michoacan Echota Cherokee Tribe of Alabama Slovakia genetic determinism Arabia Colin Pitchfork Puerto Rico Nancy Gentry Cherokee DNA Sizemore surname George van der Merwede Jesse Montes Chris Tyler-Smith education Helladic art bar mitzvah pipe carving N. Brent Kennedy BATWING Waynesboro Pennsylvania Hebrew inscriptions James Shoemaker Asiatic Echoes Richmond California Isabel Allende b'nei anousim DNA security Svante Paabo Israel, Shlomo Sand INORA Acadians Timothy Bestor Riane Eisler Rebecca L. Cann Tara MacIsaac Leicester Melba Ketchum bloviators powwows Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act Salt River Early Jews of England and Wales Paleolithic Age Life Technologies Anne C. Stone family history Monya Baker Mucogee Creeks surnames Cave art Phyllis Starnes Elvis Presley DNA Miguel Gonzalez BBCNews French Canadians Carl Zimmer Albert Einstein College of Medicine Sasquatch Choctaw Indians Arabic climate change EURO DNA Fingerprint Test occipital bun ethnicity Neolithic Revolution Mildred Gentry Virginia genealogy FBI clinical chemistry Nature Genetics GlobalFiler Black Dutch China Cherokee Freedmen B'nai Abraham human migrations Bryan Sykes oncology university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Richard III Rare Genes genomics labs Jalisco Illumina Phillipe Charlier Charlemagne Science magazine Holy Roman Empire NPR Harold Sterling Gladwin private allele mental foramen Phoenix DNA magazine Tumamoc Hill Scientific American Douglas Preston The Nation magazine CODIS markers haplogroup U Mary Settegast medicine Irish history single nucleotide polymorphism Joel E. Harris George Starr-Bresette Ethel Cox human leukocyte testing Khoisan Oxford Journal of Evolution National Health Laboratories Peter Parham corn Secret History of the Cherokee Indians phenotype Moundbuilders Colin Renfrew Marie Cheng haplogroup W PNAS evolution National Geographic Daily News Sir Joshua Reynolds Monica Sanowar Melungeons methylation Khazars personal genomics Sizemore Indians DNA Fingerprint Test history of science Richard Dewhurst Havasupai Indians New York Academy of Sciences population genetics Charles Perou haplogroup Z Melungeon Movement New York Times Epoch Times Celts Tutankamun King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales research Stephen Oppenheimer Gregory Mendel Antonio Torroni Holocaust Michael Schwartz Richard Buckley Kentucky epigenetics Elizabeth C. Hirschman Abenaki Indians Ron Janke Jim Bentley peopling of the Americas seafaring Gila River African DNA New York Review of Books Walter Plecker American history Robinson Crusoe Jewish genetics John Wilwol art history far from the tree Turkic DNA haplogroup J Stephen A. Leon Plato Italy population isolates ancient DNA Zionism Hispanic ancestry Caucasian haplogroup E Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma Daily News and Analysis pheromones Indo-Europeans MHC Jack Goins Washington D.C. Kari Schroeder North Carolina Taino Indians Myra Nichols Europe Y chromosomal haplogroups Roma People Native American DNA Test Bradshaw Foundation Wikipedia Hadassah Magazine Charles Darwin Romania Oxford Nanopore Rich Crankshaw Patrick Pynes Irish DNA Scotland Gypsies IntegenX microsatellites Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis origins of art When Scotland Was Jewish Dienekes Anthropology Blog Douglas Owsley Stony Creek Baptist Church Bode Technology Luca Pagani rapid DNA testing haplogroup D Kennewick Man Michael Grant Barack Obama Abraham Lincoln London Henriette Mertz Alia Garcia-Ureste Odessa Shields Cox haplogroup G Zuni Indians Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America andrew solomon consanguinity Family Tree DNA Middle Eastern DNA Solutreans Columbia University Britain Bureau of Indian Affairs Magdalenian culture palatal tori John Butler health and medicine Population genetics Finnish people King Arthur Ostenaco Tucson Johnny Depp American Journal of Human Genetics Kurgan Culture Ireland Smithsonian Magazine archeology prehistoric art Bering Land Bridge India Indian Territory FOX News Yates surname M. J. Harper Discovery Channel Genome Sciences Building Constantine Rafinesque Majorca Russia Alabama Holocaust Database haplogroup B Discover magazine genetic memory James Stritzel Austro-Hungary Bigfoot Mexico rock art Nadia Abu El-Haj David Reich Hohokam Indians Dragging Canoe Patrick Henry haplogroup R Jan Ravenspirit Franz Harry Ostrer Bill Tiffee Penny Ferguson Keros Panther's Lodge Publishers El Castillo cave paintings District of Columbia polydactylism Thruston Tablet Middle Ages Victor Hugo Rush Limbaugh cancer Y chromosome DNA ISOGG Altai Turks

Archive